Sebald particularly praised Der Untergang, Hans Erich Nossack’s account of the July firebombing of Hamburg, which was included in a. Buy Der Untergang by Hans Erich Nossack (ISBN: ) from Amazon’s Book Store. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Hans Erich Nossack (30 January – 2 November ) was a German writer . Among his works are Spätestens im November (), Der jüngere Bruder.
|Published (Last):||21 October 2011|
|PDF File Size:||17.94 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||6.78 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Foreword by Joel Agee. Plus, a great perspective on the victimhood that Germans felt post World War 2. Feb 09, Colleen rated it really liked it. There is something consoling in it, but it is precisely that consolation that makes us feel naked and helpless, at the mercy of a force that wants to destroy us.
You are commenting using your Twitter account. Volker Hage, Hamburg Personal accounts like these are best when they are passionate, descriptive, and most of all, concise. Why do they try to lie to the dead?
Mar 29, Christiane Alsop rated it liked it Shelves: It’s far above the shallow american movies like the rise of the evil, the boy in strpped pijamas, and Valkyre. Everything we did immediately lost its meaning. And the others, and those who will come later? It is not a terribly useful history, and definitely not the “remarkable firsthand account” promised by the publisher. It is the voice of a witness—not in the usual juridical sense, but in the confessional sense of religious parlance, though he brings no good news and says nothing of God: All but one of them were works of fiction, some of it quite fantastical, and the single piece of reportage proper, titled Der Untergang i —an account of the destruction of Hamburg by Allied bombers in July, —gave way, intermittently, to passages written in the language of dreams and fairytales.
The questioning tone of these sentences suggests ambivalence, perhaps disapproval of what they propose, but with the very next sentence Sebald goes on to praise Untertang for having described the movements of refugees in such a way that they could indeed serve as material for a behaviorist study.
It had nothing to do with it. I pray that my children will never have to endure something like ungergang. With a scientific account of the previously unknown phenomenon of the firestorms?
The End: Hamburg 1943
To deny an event its past is to make it appear as if it were fate, to destroy the linearity of the causal timeline so that events appear as expressions of Necessity. Trivia About The End: I was living in New York then. In fact he applied to them noseack that right, and they unteegang it, but then prevented him from publishing a volume of poems on the grounds that there was a shortage of paper.
A most efich book written so lyrically that a year later I still see the images Nossack paints via language. The conventional biography was that of a coffee merchant and, later, a professional writer of considerable renown, a founding member of three academies and Vice President of a fourth, an active member of the P.
Joel Agee – Foreword: The End, by Hans Erich Nossack
The book is a short book and delves a great deal into the feelings of the author and people he met coping with the devastation of their lives after this singular event. He wrote his account four months after the events in November and was clearly still in shock.
Talk of domestic matters? After all, many people lost children or spouses or friends; what is the loss of even the most treasured object compared to that? If there had been such a little something, how we would have caressed it; it would have been imbued with the essence of all the other things.
Everything that men have to say about this is a lie. You are commenting using your WordPress. Sebald noted, that describes the Allied bombing campaign from the German perspective. I founded it tedious and at times incoherent. Nossack and a friend watched the firebombing of Hamburg from afar and then had to go back and deal with it. But actually the concept of ‘street’ no longer existe Hans Erich Nossack, writer and coffee merchant, former student Communist, watched the bombing of Hamburg from a rural vacation cabin and returned to a city reich rubble.
The living are not to be trusted. At times Nossak does this, as when he describes the thirty-seven people who were trapped in a bomb shelter that was directly adjacent to a coal bin that had caught fire. Watching others applaud each time an Allied plane is downed, he declines to join in.
Nov 05, Daniel Cheng rated it liked it. Bibliography Photo-Embedded Literature — With a pathological record of typical modes of death, or with behaviorist studies of the instincts of flight and homecoming? Eschewing academic approaches for a more personal essay, Sebald approaches the complex issues of German guilt and Allied moral culpability through the more informal avenues of lecture and essay, rather than developing a ddr argued case.
Today the number again wavers between sixty thousand and a hundred thousand, and no one dares to object. Paperbackpages. I mean, why record all this?
Der Untergang : Hans Erich Nossack :
As a description of the Allied firebombing of Hamburg during WWII, this slim volume doesn’t offer much in the way of details. Why did we collect provision and save money? Jul 08, Haans rated it it was amazing. Do not translate text that appears unreliable or low-quality. Indeed, it seems that no German writer, with the sole exception of Nossack, nossqck ready or able to put any concrete facts down on paper about the progress and repercussions of this gigantic, long-term campaign of destruction.
Really thought it would be a matter of days for the whole thing to end 33 “impotence of untegang state” 34 He says there was no general feeling of hatred toward enemy or wish that it had happened to others. That would be a simple statement such as the dead, too, could understand. About Hans Erich Nossack. Just wanting to offer them help seemed too loud an action.
He explores envy of victims.